Leafs Trade Rumors

07 Dec 2025 17:36:56
To Tor
Schenn
Lambert
To Wpg
Robertson
Benoit

To Tor
Rinzel
Greene
To chi
Carlo
Maccelli


Instead of Murphy I'd rather one of the young 3 rd on Chicago. Rinzel puck mover and only 21yrs old. Schenn stay at home plays hard blocks shots and hits. Berube man. Lambert needs new start young c/rw. Hence Robertson swap. Cause Maccelli won't get him.

Knies Matthews Domi
Cowan Tavares nylander
Joshua Roy McMann
Lorentz Laughton Greene

Rielly schenn
McCabe Rinzel
OEL Stecher
Until Tanev returns if he does not looking good

Hildeby
Akhtyamov

Until Woll and Stolarz return

07 Dec 2025 12:35:00
Tor: Robertson
Rights to niemela
Conditional 28' 3rd (becomes a 2nd if leafs resign)

Nyi: JP Pageau 50%

Tor: Thrun
Domi
Ana: Vatrano

I'll admit it probably takes more to get vatrano but he's a player I'm targeting simply because he seems like a guy that is being buried because of their young guy emerging not because he's a bad player.

The Pageau trade is one I've been throwing out there since last year when they had no centre's he'd be a rental most likely but it gives the leafs a guy to play with Laughton he has a strong two way game plays physical and would improve the pk so the leafs don't have to use Matthews there anymore I like Robby he's come along way but he's too inconsistent and he's an offensive guy who's always gonna be buried in the bottom six

But both these trade is make "if" the leafs are in or close to a playoff spot come January

07 Dec 2025 16:06:56
Top 6 RW is bigger priority.

07 Dec 2025 22:28:22
Leafs don’t have the assets to get that done without moving Cowan and or danford which I don’t think the leafs are willing to do so how do they get a top 6 guy my solution is build an even strong team with more depth vatrano is more than capable of playing in a top six role was an all star not long ago and put up 3 consecutive 20+ goal seasons the last three years.

05 Dec 2025 22:30:46
Leafs trade
Carlo
Maccelli
Picks? Maybe a 2nd

Canucks trade
Garland
Myers

Knies Matthew's garland
Cowan Tavares nylander
Joshua Roy McCann
Lorentz Laughton Domi

Reilly Tanev
McCabe stretcher
OEL myers
Benoit

You'd have to find a way to move out jarnkrok or some other contract to get under cap

06 Dec 2025 00:16:37
Can’t really see any advantage for the Canucks in making this trade.
Myers is playing as well or better than Carlo.
Garland is far far far better than Maccelli could ever hope to be.
The 2nd round pick is merely a shot in the dark.

06 Dec 2025 15:09:32
Only bonus for nucks is age difference in the swap. They get much younger.

07 Dec 2025 02:19:13
Laughable
Get serious.

04 Dec 2025 20:13:36
Penguins have been reeling a bit lately. Have some guys hurt. Dubas is familiar with Jarnkrok.

Pens
Jarnkrok $2.1M

Toronto
Poulin $.775M
2027 4th

Pens get a familiar player to Dubas who can fill a lot of different roles and gives Jarnkrok a fresh start where he is likely to play more regularly.

Leafs pick up a good sized C/W that needs a new opportunity. Mostly stuck in the minors in Pitt, he will be a group 6 UFA end of season. Leafs get a 4th in 2027 to make up some value and clear some cap space.

Both Jarnkrok and Poulin are pending free agents. Poulin is quite a bit younger at only 24.

05 Dec 2025 13:32:35
The way the Leafs are playing right now, this is the only kind of move I would make right now. Pick up a draft pick for a player that needs a change of scenery.

06 Dec 2025 00:27:35
I would think that it would be the Penguins receiving the 4th round pick for taking on Jarnkrok’s $2.1 million dollar contract.

I would prefer Tomasino for Jarnkrok as Tomasino is a young, former 1st round pick, a right wing, still trying to find his way.
Excellent skater, good hands, but like most young offensive players needs to refine his two way game,
Right wing is a position of weakness, with the Leafs only having Nylander (besides Jarnkrok whom we are sending out) to fill the need.

06 Dec 2025 16:10:56
WB. Penguins shouldn't be worried about taking on Jarnkrok's cap hit or money since his bonus would have been paid and he only makes $.775M as a salary. Pens have lots of cap room. Jarnkrok is a useful player.
Poulin is also a former 1st round pick, actually chosen a couple spots ahead of Tomasino in the same draft. Like Tomasino, he has done very well in the A. He is bigger and also a centre. Although a left shot, he often plays the right side when playing on the wing. Take into account Tomasino carries a $1.75M cap hit compared to Poulin's $.775M as well. If the Leafs want cap space, Tomasino doesn't give them that, but Poulin does. Poulin has always been in the Pens organization and Tomasino is on his second team and can't claim a regular NHL spot.

07 Dec 2025 02:21:40
Moving deck chairs on the Titanic.

07 Dec 2025 17:22:29
It's not moving deck chairs. It is creating cap space and getting back a 24 year old that may still have upside for a 34 year old who is in the press box anyway.

01 Dec 2025 21:10:04
I am hearing some talk about Mo for Nurse. I don't mind it, both players need a change of scenery. Nurse is one year younger, tougher and about the same as Mo defensively. Maybe not quite as good offensively.
The other target I would go after is Kane in Vcr. I lived in Edmonton when Kane played for the Oilers, and he made Tkachuk and Bennett a non-factor in the playoff series.
Maybe Robertson for Kane? Not sure how the money would work, but a fair trade for both teams.

01 Dec 2025 22:52:11
Don’t care much for either Nurse or Reilly’s game.
Evander Kane’s attitude has always turned me off to the player.
I think I would prefer to keep Robertson.

02 Dec 2025 07:01:51
Stay away from nurse. He's looked brutal and costs more.

02 Dec 2025 20:19:01
You’re hearing that where? Lol.

02 Dec 2025 22:02:34
I personally love it. We aren’t winning anything until this group becomes tougher. We are way too soft to compete in playoffs still. Those two would be a huge boost for playoffs. and like Dave said, Kane made Bennett and Tkachuk a non factor because they had someone to answer the bell for those two meatballs.

03 Dec 2025 17:42:41
My guess is the people that are opposed to the Kane and Nurse trade are also the ones that were against the Bennet trade.
"Doug MacLean stopped by the 'Real Kyper & Bourne Show' on Monday and mentioned how the Leafs should consider a trade proposal that would send Rielly to the Edmonton Oilers in exchange for Darnell Nurse"

04 Dec 2025 01:32:26
Since when have we ever seen a rumour presented by the media that ever comes to fruition. lol leafs fans are so delusional.

04 Dec 2025 02:45:10
That is not a trade rumour, it is a suggestion by MacLean. It's just an opinion, not talk.

01 Dec 2025 01:08:18
tor: domi, quillan

clb: coyle (50%)

01 Dec 2025 10:23:27
Love to get rid of Domi.
Don’t want to let Quillan or any other young guys go.
At least not for the soon to be 34 year old Coyle.

01 Dec 2025 12:53:16
Listen, if you're not going to get anything if you're not willing to move prospects. That's been the most annoying comment the posters here keep trying to not trade anyone they like. But you're not gonna get anything good, if you're not giving anything good.

01 Dec 2025 22:56:07
And the 34 year old Coyle is that good?

02 Dec 2025 14:07:06
He's a 50% faceoff right handed center who can also right wing in a 3rd line situation to get the depth scoring really pumping.