Leafs rumours 2

30 Nov 2025 16:49:30
Two trades I think that could becoming,

Toronto trades Marcelli, Carlo

To

Nashville for Bunting, Perbix and a 2nd in 2026

Toronto trades Robertson, Benoit

To

Anaheim for Pavel Mintyukov, Ross Johnson and a 2nd in 2026

(Need more toughness on Fourth line with Johnson on the right side)

Toronto trades Domi
To
San Jose for 4th in 2026
(For cap space)

30 Nov 2025 17:40:04
Pretty reasonable.

30 Nov 2025 18:29:26
My understanding is perbix is untouchable.

29 Nov 2025 21:23:32
LA Kings
Matthews
Carlo
McMann
Quillan


Leafs
Byfield
Clarke
Greentree
2nd 2026
1st 2027

01 Dec 2025 10:25:42
Unbelievable but love it!

Take away the 1st and 2nd round picks and maybe that fool Holland will start talking.

29 Nov 2025 12:11:50
To tor
Nazar
Greene
Crevier
Murphy
1st 2026,1st 2028, 2nd 2026,2nd 2027

To Chi
Matthews
Carlo

29 Nov 2025 21:02:07
I know everyone might think this is crazy, but I’m really pushing for a trade like this. Get rid and f Mathews, Nylander. And Mo. if you’re gonna say that you’re changing the”DNA”, then do it. Not this trade in particular but a big trade getting in some new pieces to form the DNA we want. I’m m big on a Columbus trade with Marchenko, Olivier being a part of the deal. We don’t get toughness in the lineup, we will continue to get bullied for a decade in a row now.

Mathews, Maccelli, Reilly to CJB
Marchenko, Werenski, Olivier to Tor * yes we all have an opinion on who should add here but I think the Leafs will have to add another prospect or significant draft pick to this deal because of Werenski.

Nylander to ANH
McTavish, Sennecke, 2nd rd pick 2026 to Tor

Knies JT Marchenko
McMann McTavish Cowan
Robertson Roy Sennecke
Joshua Laughton Olivier
Lorentz Domi Jarnkrok extras

Werenski OEL
McCabe Tanev
Rifai Carlo
Benoit.

30 Nov 2025 15:56:01
Trading any of Matthews, Nyalnder and/ or Rielly will be extremely difficult because they all have no moves. Remember when Tkachuk wanted out of Calgary, he gave Calgary one option he was willing to go to. At the time it looked like Calgary got a really good return considering the circumstances. Then Hubey sucked and the trade looked horrible.
It sounds great to get all these good to great prop returns for these guys, but reality will likely be that they refuse to waive, will only waive for one or two teams which will mean the return is not what we would hope for or many won't be happy with. The players completely control this situation.

29 Nov 2025 11:56:09
To Tor
Beniers
Dunn
Marchement
Wright
1st 2026,1st 2027, 2nd 2027,4th 2026

To Sea
Matthews
Rielly
Robertson
Quillan

30 Nov 2025 13:43:49
@clarky. 100% I agree! It’s time! I enjoy both trades would take both as well. If Anaheim takes the Nylander deal I’d be asking Willy to go shopping for some new shades and suits asap. Matthews as well, I agree for a “ DNA “ change we need to change the core of said DNA. After those few trades I think we’d be fine and back into the playoff picture in no time, if not immediately.

30 Nov 2025 13:47:45
** @clarky IF there’s a add from Tor it’s whatever to get it done. Not a fan of it but throw in Danford to get it done if that’s the pick prospect u thinks needed. Maybe even another 2nd. Just get it done already Tre.

01 Dec 2025 10:31:17
That’s a damaged Matthews and a bunch of nothing to Seattle for Seattle’s top forward, top defenseman and two high end roll players.
Can’t see it.

Matthews has lost a lot of his value have gone missing in action for the past year and a quarter and still has not seemed to put the injuries behind him.
At best Matthews is a top 15. - 20 player in the league and that might be pushing it a little.

29 Nov 2025 11:23:43
To tor
Perfetti
Schenn
Lambert
To Win
Carlo
Robertson
Maccelli

01 Dec 2025 10:34:19
Can’t see Winnipeg doing that.
Maccell is no more than an expiring contract.
Robertson a 5’ 9”, 3rd line energy player, and Carlo has not exactly distinguished himself since coming to the Leafs in the trade with Boston.

29 Nov 2025 01:21:17
Question,

Would any of you make this trade,

Toronto trades Robertson and Matthews

To

Utah for Logan Cooley,Nick Schmaltz, 1st, 2nd 3rd in 2026

29 Nov 2025 11:10:25
Give me Crouse instead of schmaltz.

30 Nov 2025 15:59:46
The only issue with getting young guys and picks for Matthews/ Nylander is the age of the Leafs defence. You either use the gained assets (prospects/ picks/ cap space) to acquire proven players to improve now, or you are also rebuilding the defence, asking D-men to move on and going full rebuild except in net.

01 Dec 2025 10:36:14
I think the Mammoth would be very foolish to make that trade.
Matthews is 28 year old, damaged goods.

28 Nov 2025 12:24:24
To Tor
Hughes
Sherwood
Debrusk
Kane
To Van
Rielly
Knies
Maccelli
Robertson
Hildeby

To Tor
Marchement
To Sea
Mcmann
Domi




Blockbuster. 2 teams that need an overhaul. Hate to see Knies go but need to include to get Norris calibre D. I think with this line up you shore up top six and bottom six. Also b4 giving up on Carlo see how he does beside Hughes. Kane, Sherwood, Marchement come off the books end of season. If they fit u sign them if not you got Hughes and Debrusk out of the deal and money to put towards Hughes extension plus great cap space for FA market. Still move guys in off season. This is more of a berube line up. 4 balanced lines that can get good playing time.

Debrusk Matthews Sherwood
Marchement Tavares nylander
Kane Roy Cowan
Joshua Laughton Lorentz

Hughes Carlo
McCabe Tanev
OEL Stecher/benoit

Woll
Stolarz

Crucify it boys. Let's here the 🥴 experts

29 Nov 2025 00:41:53
Left one move out Benoit for Gudas. Dump Stecher on waivers.

28 Nov 2025 00:53:18
William Nylander and Mick Robertson for Andrei Svechnikov and Logan Stankoven

28 Nov 2025 12:27:14
Willy is going nowhere. Neither is Matthews until next seasons trade deadline at earliest not this season.

01 Dec 2025 10:38:08
We need change and this is change.
Unfortunately it leaves the Leafs with only the 35 year old Tavares as a top 6 center.

28 Nov 2025 00:22:56
The proposals get more and more far fetched as Leafs flounder at or near the bottom of the Eastern Conference.
Số here is one to sink your teeth into.

To St Louis: Matthews ($13.25), Carlo ($3.485) = $16.735

To Leafs: Robert Thomas ($8.125), Jordan Kyrou ($8.125) = $16.25

Might have to fire Berube after making this deal 🤓😆

28 Nov 2025 14:55:47
Not really on board for this one. Neither of these Blues players play a very physical game, so yes, you probably have to fire Berube. Both are having down seasons. Nor do either produce much in the playoffs for the most part. Kyrou is a bit of a headcase imo. Typically he has been a liability defensively. Not a guy I would really target. For the most part I like Thomas, but it seems like a so-so return for Matthews alone, never-mind throwing in Carlo where Toronto's defence gets weaker and getting no cap relief at all.

29 Nov 2025 11:13:30
Thomas for Matthews straight up is ridiculous. If u r giving up a d one needs to come back has to b a RD. Kyrou is overrated.

29 Nov 2025 17:51:25
No one said Matthews for Thomas straight up. The point was although Thomas is a good player, even adding Kyrou seems like a so-so return for Matthews especially when adding Carlo and no cap savings.

28 Nov 2025 00:06:55
Auston Matthews to the Columbus Blue Jackets for Adamo Fantilli and Luca Pinelli

29 Nov 2025 11:14:53
Are ppl serious with these Matthews proposals? The guy is the leading scorer since entering the league and in his prime. Ridiculous postings IMO.

01 Dec 2025 10:22:08
@blow ya people are serious. The proposals may not be realistic or even something that would actually be entertained but! I think at this point we have to look at the results and be realistic. 34 would bring us a large return very large even. It is time to rethink this team and change the DNA. The core needs to go! Knies is the only player I would say is untouchable, unless Cale Makar is coming back to us. Or a Def of his calibre at least.

28 Nov 2025 00:03:51
To Tor
Dunn
Marchement
To Sea
Rielly
Mcmann
Maccelli

To Tor
Myers
Sherwood
To Van
Carlo
Robertson
Jarnkrok

To

Knies Matthews Sherwood
Cowan Tavares nylander
Marchement Roy Domi
Joshua Laughton Lorentz

Dunn Myers
McCabe Tanev
OEL Stecher
Benoit

Woll
Stolarz

Myers on waivers.