Leafs trade rumours 5

23 Nov 2025 06:53:28
Reilly to anywhere for a 7th or some assets he sucks so slow on pp and def. Maybe him plus for mink in ANA? Stecher stepped in and immediately faster than most on our d end. Sorry Benoit your a 7th d

Joshua should be gone guys useless can’t even hit why did we trade for him?

Tor: Joshua, pick

Stl: Mathieu Joseph

Tor: Robertson, 2028 1st, Macelli

Car: Svech

Knies -am- svech
Cowboy-jt-Willy
Mcmann-Roy-domi
Lorentz-Laughton-joseph/ calle / blais

McCabe - Tanev
Oel- Carlo
Mink- stecher / Hank.

23 Nov 2025 11:58:54
That D sucks. Who is Hank.

23 Nov 2025 14:29:11
Were you ? when h posted this? Svech not going anywhere. He’d back on first line mins are up and 12pts in last 13 games. That package gets laughed at.

22 Nov 2025 23:52:03
Matthews Jarnkrok to Ducks
McTavish Sennecke Mintyukov to Leafs

23 Nov 2025 14:31:41
Needs to be a 1st rd pick in that package for Tor.

23 Nov 2025 15:14:03
@Blow buddy has Matthews trade value tanked that much? Month or so ago and people would almost have said Matthews alone gets that from Anaheim. Now…. I’m not saying I don’t see who’s being asked for back but a first from Toronto too? Ok so where’s Matthews value right now just curious. If a 28’ 1st was also offered think Anaheim would bite?

21 Nov 2025 19:26:39
We need a tough guy that can play in our lineup. Team plays much tougher when they have someone that can answer the bell. Plus Ive never really been a fan of Willy. Super inconsistent and his defensive woes cost us games a lot of times. But everyone forgets that when he scores a nice goal.

To ClB: Nylander, Maccelli

To ToR: Marchenko, Olivier, Boone Jenner, 2nd rd pick 2026.

21 Nov 2025 19:58:21
Nylander has been one of the leafs most consistent player in the last 3-4 years.

21 Nov 2025 20:57:51
Nylander alone gets that and more.

22 Nov 2025 00:13:32
Yes CKPS. I’m also paying them for taking Maccelli. This guy has 0 value and doesn’t fit the so called “DNA” they are suppose to be going after. Don’t see anyone giving us an asset for this guy. Couldn’t make Utah and shouldn’t be in this team either.

22 Nov 2025 23:45:14
Clarky?
Are you in there?

23 Nov 2025 14:41:07
Nylander is a goal scorer and points getter not a tough guy. Berube is an idiot plain and simple. There has to be a balance in a roster. U lost marner and instead of getting good snot players trev goes and gets Macelli and Joshua. 2 guys thrown away from their respective teams. Roy solved 3c problem. If u were looking for production then u sign roslovic that got 22 goals last season and has 9 goals and 17pts already. Sign 1 or 2 snot guys not throw away and give up good draft pics for them.

19 Nov 2025 06:18:16
Some trade ideas

Tor: Carlo holinka
Nsh: skjei

Tor: Reilly
Van: kane 2nd

Tor: maccelli
Chi: korchiski

19 Nov 2025 17:32:58
Reilly is having his best year in a while why would we trade him. Also why in gods green earth would Chicago do that trade.

19 Nov 2025 22:16:08
Because he’s a defender who has sucked doing his job.

19 Nov 2025 23:04:09
Korchinski was a top 10, 1st round pick drafted 7th overall.
Defense is a roll that takes a lot longer to learn at the NHL level.
Why, pray tell would Chicago trade him for a complete waste of cap space like Maccelli who has zero value?

I would give Reilly to Vancouver for nothing số Kane would be a bonus and no 2nd round pick would be necessary.

Brady Skej is no better a defenseman than Carlo plus Skjei is a LHD which Leafs don’t need while Carlo is a RHD a position Leafs do need.
Making this trade would mean Leafs gave up their 2026 - 1st round pick, Frazer Minten and Holinka for Brady Skjei.
No Thank You!

19 Nov 2025 23:22:12
@Leafsgm That's the issue. He's paid extremely fair for what he produces. He's always had defensive issues, but that isn't his job.

He really has lacked a partner his entire career and Carlo is no exception now.

20 Nov 2025 00:11:31
Ok so maybe we can’t target the Ducks as they’re looking like they’re headed to future juggernaut territory aha. So…….

Tor Trades AM34 Nick Robertson and maccelli

For

Columbus Trades Chinahkov Olivier Marchenko and Cole Sillinger.

Would you take this kick start? Fairly young lots of talent size and toughness.

20 Nov 2025 05:27:25
Here’s my take on these trades Reilly needs to go idc how many secondary assists he puts up we can’t keep moving the goal post for him he’s been here how many years and it’s always “trying to find him a partner” move him to Vancouver for kane who only has a year left at least kane plays with a set.

Leafs add skjei to replace Reilly skjei is more reliable the Reilly something leafs could use and if the leafs are hell bent on moving Carlo then I’d look at this trade. as for the Chicago trade I think the blackhawks have shown they have chose other d prospects so he may be available for a player whose under control land can help them now….

20 Nov 2025 17:16:58
Henry…. Matthews alone gets way more than that. Chinakov is a healthy scratch on a below average team.

22 Nov 2025 16:23:08
Ok CKps I hear ya but……. Matthews has injury issues plus he’s fallen off a cliff with point production atm so? There’s was more then Marchenko offered in the deal. So who then? Columbus was the targeted team.

18 Nov 2025 08:12:42
Toronto needs a change. Here’s one idea:
McMann + Järnkrok and Domi would go to Utah along with Travis Boyd, and in return the Maple Leafs would receive Lawson Crouse and Kevin Stenlund.

18 Nov 2025 20:33:16
Wishful thinking.

18 Nov 2025 22:20:15
Why McMann? One of our only players playing with heart so we should just trade him? Love to hear your train of thought behind moving McMann who makes 1.35M. Don’t get it.

19 Nov 2025 00:55:32
I like Lawson Crouse.
He can play LW on the 2nd line and add some physicality to the Leafs top 6 where all physicality comes from the bottom 6.
If that takes McMann, số be it.
If McMann was 20 - 25 I would not consider trading him.
But he will be 30 in June and thus becomes expendable imo.

19 Nov 2025 01:14:46
He is one of the few that might have some trade value! got to give something to get something.

19 Nov 2025 13:52:05
Ok so McMann is the same age as these two and better than both of them. Neither one of these guys has breakout speed like McMann does plus he seems to be one of the few buying into the system. Not to mention his shot, compete level, board battles, defensive side of the puck. He has these two beat in every category and makes almost 1/ 4 of what Crouse does. Still don’t make any sense to me. What else you got?

19 Nov 2025 16:04:21
Lawson Crouse will be 29 in June. So, McMann is one year older. So what?
I like Crouse, but it's not like he brings more than McMann. 12 goals last year and on pace for 16 this year is Crouse at $4.3M for another year. McMann is on pace for 20 again this year and makes $1.35M. If the Leafs re-sign McMann, it is unlikely it is for anything much more than Crouse already makes. As Clarky noted, McMann has speed and size, which is difficult to find, especially on the cheap.

19 Nov 2025 23:15:46
Sorry RLF.
Completely disagree with you on this.
Crouse had a down year last year but he was also a 20 goal scorer the two previous years.
McMann is terribly inconsistent and streaky.
He went the last 24 games plus the playoffs without scoring a single goal.
McMann is a great skater but offers little in the way of physicality.
All Leafs physicality is in the bottom 6 and 3rd defensive pairing.
Crouse would bring a level of physicality to the top 6 that they simply don’t have.
There is also the factor that Maccelli is next to worthless on the Leafs số targeting Crouse over Maccelli this past summer would have been a MUCH wiser move by the not very bright, Treliving.

20 Nov 2025 13:08:54
WB49
All good to disagree.
How does McMann offer little in physicality though? 2nd on the team amongst forwards in hits. Stood up for Laughton against Zadorov. Goes to the net and battles. Battles along the boards. If you mean as a fighter, yes Crouse is better. Crouse also costs over 3X as much.
Crouse is a 3rd liner in Utah. Was last year as well. Others have passed him by on the depth chart.
Lets look at it from a stat you like to quote as to why to not trade for a guy. Crouse is a career -52. Bobby McMann a career +22. Doesn't that just kind of end the discussion right there? :)

17 Nov 2025 23:05:52
AM34 Jarnkrok to the Ducks
McTavish Sennecke Colangelo Luneau to Leafs

18 Nov 2025 00:22:21
Ducks have no good reason to make this trade.

6 months ago? Maybe, yeah.

18 Nov 2025 00:46:47
I'd be expecting at least 2 draft picks coming back in a Matthews trade.

18 Nov 2025 00:52:14
I don’t know if it is believable but I like the trade.

18 Nov 2025 15:26:27
How bout adding a goalie to the deal. Ducks thin on goalies.
That would get u a 1st rd 2026 anc a 2nd rd 2027. Which ducks have 3 at the moment.

17 Nov 2025 20:48:24
It's time to re think where we are as a team..in my mind there needs to be a major shake up. My theory is as follows:

Toronto : Trades Austin Matthews

Anaheim: Trades RW Beckett Sennecke(19yr)
RD Drew Helleson(24yr)
1st and 2nd round pick 2026

17 Nov 2025 22:59:58
Add Luneau and Colangelo
I will add Jarnkrok and Benoit and Hildeby.

17 Nov 2025 23:31:21
I’d take it if Anaheim says yes. I’d even take Roger McQueen, Helleson a first and 2nd to kick this rebuild.

17 Nov 2025 23:58:10
That’s not a bad return for Matthews as hockey talent goes.
But, if you are trading Matthews that leaves only the 35 year old Tavares as a top 6 center for the Leafs
In my opinion, a center as part of the return package is a must.
Something like:

To Nashville: Matthews

To Leafs, Brady Martin (C), Luke Evangelists (RW), Nicolas Hague, 1st round pick, plus Marchessault to make the cap work.

Or

To LA Kings: Matthews

To Leafs: Quinton Byfield (C), Brandt Clarke (RHD), Liam Greentree, 2026 - 1st round pick

These are just suggestions but include a young higher end center for the future.

18 Nov 2025 00:23:10
Ducks have no reason to make this trade.

18 Nov 2025 00:54:18
I don’t think the Leafs can afford to trade Matthews unless a top 6 center is coming pack as part of the return package.
Two right wingers and draft picks doesn’t do it for me.

18 Nov 2025 11:45:10
At WB, I’d do the LAK trade in a second. Byfield is good not great. Clarke is sick and Greenetree looks like he’s gonna be real good. It’s a solid start after trading Matthews. This new foundation would round into a problem.

17 Nov 2025 18:46:07
Habs need a centre.

Domi to MTL for whatever you can get. Move off of his ridiculous contract.

17 Nov 2025 20:42:25
I really don't think he's as bad as everyone says.

He is not a centre. We have known this for years, yet he keeps being put at C.

Maybe out him back on the wing in the middle 6 like he should be.

17 Nov 2025 22:59:46
It doesn’t matter where he plays. He’s highly overpaid for what he delivers. The novelty of having Tie’s kid on the team as long worn off.

17 Nov 2025 23:00:39
I would take a 3rd round pick for him.

17 Nov 2025 23:28:42
LL. He's not as bad as many say. But every Leaf player is going to be compared to the top players in the League at that position. Matthews isn't the best 1st line centre in the league so he is crap. This goes for every position down to 13th forward, 7th defenceman and 3rd string goalie.

18 Nov 2025 00:03:03
Domi not as bad as everyone says?

Domi is a team leading (-10) in only 12:47 average TOI.
Another serious blunder by Treliving.
$3.7 x 4 years.
What was Treliving thinking?

18 Nov 2025 00:48:08
Guys got to stop hating on the guy who's been bounced around to every line and gotten no consistent offensive time.

18 Nov 2025 00:58:04
Domi has been on the ice for 18, 5 on 5 goals against in 19 games so far this season seeing only 12:47 minutes of ice time a game.

Pontus Holmberg was on was on the ice for 19, 5 on 5 goals against in 68 games last season.
Steve Lorentz was on the ice for 20, 5 on 5 goals against in 80 games last season.

Anyone who feels Domi is not a major part of the problem is following a different Leaf team than I am.

19 Nov 2025 15:58:08
Domi has been given every opportunity, including time with Matthews. He’s a one million dollar guy at best. Time to get anything you can to get out from under his salary.

17 Nov 2025 17:48:42
How about Matthews to Calgary for Kadri, Anderson and maybe a pick.
Matthews doesn't have the fire or passion to lead the Leafs. They need someone to drag them into the fight.

17 Nov 2025 18:06:51
Ya he might not have the fire for leafs but he definitely doesn’t have it for the flames. He will never go to another Canadian team he is US bound if he approves a trade.

17 Nov 2025 19:16:05
I'd consider a big move with Matthews going to Anaheim.

17 Nov 2025 21:19:05
You're probably right, Matthews would not approve a trade to Calgary. I would like to see a Kadri and Anderson type in return.

18 Nov 2025 00:05:23
Matthews for the 35 year old Kadri and nearly 30 year old Andersson?
Seriously?
Please NO!

Thankfully I don’t have worry as Matthews would NEVER approve a trade to Calgary.

18 Nov 2025 11:49:58
I could see a Matthews to Anaheim trade because A) He’s back in the US. B) The Ducks need someone a bit older and experienced I guess like Matthews. Not in Toronto Matthews will most likely go back to being AM60 type player. We on the other hand get a very solid return as mentioned in the proposals above. Idea incoming sorry.

17 Nov 2025 12:18:28
Robertson, Carlo, Stolarz, Domi, McMann and a second to Sabres

Tuch and Byram to Leafs.

17 Nov 2025 12:47:05
If Buffalo takes it…DONE!

17 Nov 2025 17:42:53
I personally wouldn’t want to move Stolarz or McMann. We are suppose to go somewhere with Woll and Hildeby?

17 Nov 2025 18:45:10
Clarky…. One of Woll or Stolarz needs to get a decent return. They are essentially the same thing.

16 Nov 2025 20:01:09
Toronto trades Domi, Marcelli, Robertson, Myers, Carlo, prospect

To

Nashville for Marchessault, Hauge, Perbix and Evangelino

Toronto trades Rielly, Jarnkroc

To

Vancouver for Tyler Myers and Kiefer Sherwood