Leafs trade rumours 5

01 Apr 2025 16:57:17
Leafs trade REAVES & Laughton

Philadelphia 5 th pick 2026

That's how badly TRELIVING did in this trade


Marner is a strange situation the Leafs could be lowballing him at $12 million with him asking $14 million

They need to sit down with Matthews and tell him Marner makes more next season. They are trying to prevent Matthews from feeling ripped off

What is best solution letting Marner walk or paying him $14 million as he knows the cap is rising ?


Salaries highest paid players

Draisaitl $14 million 8 years
Matthews $13.25 3 years left at season end
MacKinnon $12.6 `in second year 8 year deal Mcdavid. $12.5 next season is his last
Rantanen $12 million term starts next season


So it pretty easy to figure.leafs offering $12 million 8 years is too low.

Marner is better than Rantanen not as good as Draisaitl . The second factor for Marner is the cap is going way up and he wants to be compensated for that.

So give Marner $14 million

01 Apr 2025 21:00:39
Can’t pay Marner more than Matthews. Same at most. Marner is not better than Rantenen.

01 Apr 2025 23:02:44
If IF the Leafs even think about 14 for Marner they will deserve what they’ll get. NOTHING! No cup no final nothing! Guy has proven ZERO! Anyone suggesting this number is out to lunch. Sorry Mackin.

01 Apr 2025 23:23:11
Marner can flock off, I made too offer's that the Leafs should give to him before July 1st.

$12.5 million x 8 yrs. (First 6 yrs full no trade, last two no protection)
Or
$14 million x 8 yrs with no protection
(This way they can trade him at anytime)

If he says no to both then Goodbye!

01 Apr 2025 23:48:21
In what way is 12m low balling Mitchy? He collapses in the playoffs and has never hit 100pts. That doesn't deserve 12m imo.

02 Apr 2025 02:27:20
That is what the bankrobber is asking for not that I think they should do it, I would prefer that he walks so we can build a team with depth on all four lines.

23 Mar 2025 23:07:07
Trade their rights Marner/Robertson for 4th round and 5th round ! Fill out the roster!

Sign free agents
Boeser RW 7 years @ 6 million per year
Chychurn D 5 years 6 million per year
S. Bennet C 4 years @ 6 million per year
C. Brown RW 2 years @ 2 million per year
Kylington D 2 years @ 2 million per year


Re-sign
Tavares C 4 years @ 5 million per year
Knies LW/RW 5 years @ 5.5 million per year

Trade Kampf For 3rd pick to anyone
Trade Domi for 5th round pick to anyone

Toronto forward lines
Knies/Mathews/Boeser
Tavarse/Bennet/Nylander
McMann/Jarnkrok/Laughton Lorentz/Cowan/Holmberg/Brown

Toronto defensive lines
Reilly/Carlo
Macabe/Chychrun
OEL/Tanev
Myers/Benniot/Kylington

Toronto Goalies
Woll SG
Stolarz BG

24 Mar 2025 01:19:47
So every free agent takes a discount Tavares and knies both take discounts and kampf is worth more than domi in trade value lol ok.

24 Mar 2025 03:12:33
If you can get any of them to agree to those deals I'll personally build you a statue outside the gardens.

24 Mar 2025 20:22:17
Knies will be 7-8m per.

26 Mar 2025 11:56:32
Chychrun went for 9M X 8 years. Hey, at least you were close ?.

23 Mar 2025 13:24:10
at the draft trade:
Leafs trades: McMann and Benoit
to
Oilers trades: Connor Brown

2026 NHL trade deadline trade:
Leafs trades: 2028 First round pick, William Nylander, Cowan and Danford
to
Golden Knights trades: Mark Stone and Alex Pietrangelo

Hire new assistant coach:
Matt Finn

Resign
Tavares C/RW 5 years @ 5 million per year
Knies LW/RW 5 years @ 5 millions per year
Marner RW 5 years @ 5millions per year
Robertson LW 5 years @ 950k

Toronto forward lines
Knies/Mathews/Marner
Robertson /Tavares/Stone
Domi/Laughton/Brown
Lorentz/Kampf/Jarnkrok
extra: Reaves

Toronto defensive lines
Riley/Pietrangelo
Macabe/Tanev
OEL/Carlo
extra: Hankapää


Toronto's Goalies
Woll SG
Stolarz BG

23 Mar 2025 15:58:43
Your trades are absurd. Your signings are even more ridiculous. McMann alone is worth more than Connor Brown. Nylander alone gets you Stone and Petrangelo (and still wouldn’t do it) . And most obviously …. on what planet do you reside on to think you’re signing Mitch Marner at 5 million? And Knies for that matter? Marner will get $13m and Knies will approach $8m.

23 Mar 2025 15:59:54
And Nick Robertson is your second line LW? Lmao.

23 Mar 2025 20:41:53
People that trade McMann or Knies show that they have no clue what they are doing! What’s next McCabe and Tanev? Stolly or Woll?

23 Mar 2025 23:37:26
I have been following this site for years and these are easily two of the worst trades I have ever come across!

23 Mar 2025 07:54:32
Leafs trade Jarnknok Kampf Domi Reaves

SAN JOSE 3 rd round pic 25 and 6 th 2026


We must give Steeves another chance if he gets going it adds playoff scoring. Steeves had better numbers when McMann and Steeves last played 60 plus games on same Marlie team

I think you hold onto Robertson he is playing well and I think with some luck he has as many goals and points as Bobby McMann. These two players are equal in my eyes just Bobby is more fortunate-around the net. A really nice tip in tight on Ranger goalie from McMann last night


Games Goals assists points
McMann 61. 19. 12. 31
Robertson 59. 12. 7. 19

If Leafs had to lose picks and prospects like 2 firsts and Grebenkin ,Minton now was time to lose them. With cap rising as it is Leafs will be able to add 2 more core forwards if they manage cap properly now


2024-25 $88 million
2025-26. $95.5 million
2026-27 . $104 million
2027-28. $113.5 million


I end up giving Marner what he wants max $114 . Don't be foolish that we let Marner walk and sign Sam Bennett remember they ran Bennett out of Calgary and right now his play can only get worse

Marner is a key he could play til he is 40 and he will want to finish leading the Leafs in most points in team history. Crosby loves setting that mark in Pittsburgh it so much better to lead the Leafs more history

In Flyer trade we was robbed Laughton is a 4th liner. We do have him next year at $1.5 million so we can scrap the worse players and overpaid . Domi Kampf Jarnknok and Reaves.

The only thing that saves Max is if he starts scoring as he has since moving to Wing but that needs to keep going from now through playoffs

If this group scores Leafs go far

Matthews
Marner
Nylander
Tavares
Knies
McManus
Robertson
Steeves
Pacioretty
Holmberg

23 Mar 2025 08:39:20
Hey Mackin, I could care-less if Marner has the most points in NHL history for the Leafs. Because as long as they keep the core 4, they ain’t winning a cup. But hey if that’s what’s important to you, regular season heroes, then enjoy Mackin. But I 100% disagree with most things you say and this one is no different. 10 years of the exact same result and Mackin wants to run it back with another 8 year signing to Marner. ?.

23 Mar 2025 09:26:54
Marner money could be used for two good players. I have no issue with letting him walk.

23 Mar 2025 04:44:25
Let Marner/ Robertson walk and change up the lineup!

Toronto gets
3rd round pick from anyone for Kampf C
5th round pick from anyone for Domi RW/C
5th round pick from anyone for Benoit D

Toronto signs
Elhers LW
Boeser RW
Kunin C
Chychurn D
Fabbro D
Bennett C

Resign
Tavares C/RW 5 years @ 5 million per year
Knies LW/RW 5 years @ 5 millions per year

Toronto forward lines
Knies/Mathews/Boeser
Elhers/Bennet/Nylander
Tavares/Kunin/Cowan
McMann/Jarnkrok/Lorantz

Toronto defensive lines
Riley/Carlo
Macabe/Chychurn
OEL/Tanev
Fabbro/Myers

Toronto's Goalies
Woll SG
Stolarz BG

23 Mar 2025 09:25:11
You’re not getting Knies that cheap.

24 Mar 2025 20:25:43
Knies is getting close to 8m.

23 Mar 2025 04:28:15
After the leafs have another rubbish cup run they go into the 2025 free agency and go a different direction!

Let Marner/Robertson walk! Fill out the roster!

Sign free agents
Boeser RW 7 years @ 6 million per year
Chychurn D 5 years 6 million per year
Sam Bennet C 4 years @ 6 million per year
C. Brown RW 2 years @ 2 million per year
Kylington D 2 years @ 2 million per year


Re-sign
Tavares C 4 years @ 5 million per year
Knies LW/RW 5 years @ 5 million per year

Trade Kampf For 3rd pick to anyone
Trade Domi for 5th round pick to anyone

Toronto forward lines
Knies/Mathews/Boeser
Tavarse/Bennet/Nylander
McMann/Jarnkrok/Laughton Lorentz/Cowan/Holmberg/Brown

Toronto defensive lines
Reilly/Carlo
Macabe/Chychrun
OEL/Tanev
Myers/Benniot/Kylington

Toronto Goalies
Woll SG
Stolarz BG

17 Mar 2025 18:28:08
Before July 1st

Nash
Robertson RFA
Rights to Marner

Tor
Gojsic ELC
2025 2nd

Gojsic is a recent 3rd round pick by Nashville. Big kid, right shot RW from BC. Good shot, skates well for his size. Leafs could use some right shot forward prospects.

18 Mar 2025 07:27:04
Don’t know much about the prospect but I will be interested to see if the leafs try and get anything from marner if they know he is t coming back.

18 Mar 2025 10:46:22
Yea. That was the idea of the post mostly. To get something for Marner. I like Spellacy from Chicago as well in that B prospect range.

19 Mar 2025 01:08:25
If Marner hasn’t signed by mid June it would be a good idea to trade his signing rights for assets.
Many teams would like to have first shot at Marner before he hits free agency.

A right shot wing prospect with upside would be great.
If Marner leaves the Leafs will be left with only Nylander and Jarnkrok on the right side.

19 Mar 2025 07:22:23
Hard to understand why Marner would want to leave? It’s not money and I think it’s posturing on his part. But what he doesn’t understand is this team is flawed so if they get booted in first two rounds Leafs will have to change the core and he is the only guy they can change. Tavares is a good citizen he isn’t going anywhere all he will want is fairness!

19 Mar 2025 17:56:58
@RLF I watched Spellacy in Windsor a week ago big fast kid plays hard he even got in a scrap I would say I’d rather grab picks for marner if it’s a rights deal I really wanna see the leafs trade up in this draft.

19 Mar 2025 18:47:02
Goat. Spellacy definitely plays hard. lol
Picks are fine, but do you think you are getting more than a 2nd for Marner's rights? I think Leafs could use some prospects after trading Minten and Grebenkin. Plus a propsect like Gojsic or Spellacy is much closer to playing for the Leafs than a pick would be.

22 Mar 2025 13:42:22
@RLF no I don’t think the leafs could get a 1st for his rights unless there’s a bidding war which is possible but I think it would then turn into a sign and trade which is another avenue the leafs could try.

17 Mar 2025 18:01:06
Buffalo Trades
Peterka (RFA)

Toronto Trades
NRobertson (RFA)
Hildeby (AHL)
2nd Round Pick 2025

17 Mar 2025 13:28:09
Here are my predictions for the leafs free agency

Marner walks
Robertson traded
Holmberg traded
Kampf traded

Jt 7x3 with money deferred so maybe aav is lower
Knies 7.5x6-7

Adds
Kane 3x2
Bennett if available 6x7-5-8
Faksa 1x1

Some other depth adds would be expected

So for the adds I think torontos M.O is always adding a player past their prime who was once a star I think there appeal for both sides kane replaces marner he's not the show stopper he once was but he still has game left. As for Bennett I think if he's available the leafs will go hard after him idk if I like the number it will cost but it will likely cost them and I added faksa I think he'd be a good fourth line centre to replace kampf other names I like are brazaeu kunin bjukstad also if the leafs could move Reilly I would

17 Mar 2025 23:28:22
ZERO interest in Kane. Marner walks you sign Boeser and Bennett.

18 Mar 2025 07:29:29
@bob Like I said it’s something I can see the leafs doing also got to factor in what player actually make it to July 1 so often we see big names leading up to free agency but very often they get signed.

19 Mar 2025 01:14:16
Boeser wants way too much money for what he brings to the table.
Vancouver already offered him $8 million per for 5 years and he turned it down.

No Kane’s on the Leafs, thanks!

Bennet would be a good signing.
Too bad Dubas had not traded for Bennett when he was available instead choosing to trade for Foligno (1st & 4th) for all of 7 games) .

Tavares will be 35 (September 20th) before next season starts.
I would feel more comfortable with $6 million per for 3 years.

16 Mar 2025 23:04:05
Rielly Robertson to kraken
Oleksiak 2nd 2026 to leafs

Jarnkrok kampf to devils
2nd 2026 to leafs

Holmberg Domi to jackets
3rd 2026 to Leafs


Marner Tavares sign elsewhere

Leafs sign
Bennett
Duchene
Frederic
Boeser
Provorov
Kunin
Jeannot

Knies Matthews boeser
McMann Duchene . Nylander
Frederic Bennett Cowan
Jeannot Laughton kunin
Steeves

Provorov Carlo
McCabe Tanev
Oleksiak OEL
Benoit

Woll Stolarz

17 Mar 2025 08:10:54
I don’t know if the trades would interest the Kraken, Devils or Blue Jackets but I like the lineup.

17 Mar 2025 13:05:28
Hard to say need to know what aav your putting on the free agents I think you’d be surprised at what some of those players get.

16 Mar 2025 01:14:04
Leafs trade Domi

Chicago trade 4 th 2025

The Leafs have never looked as lost as they look now. The road in the first two rounds seems to be through Florida

First 2 rounds

Leafs vs Tampa
Leafs vs Florida or Ottawa

Treliving didn't do enough at deadline and trading a first and Grebenkin seems a very heavy price for Laughton

Domi and Laughton seem to be exactly the same limited input on score sheat

The Leafs peaked a few seasons ago and are clearly going backwards. If Leafs lose in opening two rounds of playoffs they can't pay Marner $13 plus million.

With Marner not sighing during season he is pushing himself into a corner

Leafs can't win with him so maybe they win by letting him walk and keeping his cap money for free agency.


Marner Domi jarnknok kampf = $19 million in cap money

16 Mar 2025 10:28:06
Don’t forget Taveras and Reeves coming off too.
Another 12 million . Let’s go shopping!
Bennett?
Ekblad?
Provalov?