16 Nov 2026 22:54:01
If you look at the healthy roster it doesn't need that much help.
We need to shed some salary and there is one player making a lot of money that does not put in a consistent effort. So what is the best Nylander trade that he might accept a trade to?
Tor - Nylander
Mon - Hage, Zharovsky, Reinbacher
Tor Would then flip Zharovsky for a d-man
Toronto gives a player that is capable of being a top 5 winger for 3 prospects. One of which would be a center for us down the road.
Tor - Nylander
Det - Edvinsson
Det adds a top player for a player that does not want to be there.
Tor- Nylander, B level prospect, low pick
Car - Nikishin, Jarvis
Carolina adds scoring. Toronto gets 2 young pieces 1 up front and 1 defenceman.
Tor - Nylander
Cal - 1 of Cooley/Wolff, 1 of Parekh/Carels, Pospisil
Maybe Nylander will waive go to where he was born. Calgary needs top line talent but I highly doubt this one happens.
Lines
Cowan - Matthews - Roslovic
McKenna - Tavares - Marchenko
Joshua - Sissons - Paul
Duhaime - Blueger - McEwen
Reilly - Raddysh
McCabe - Tanev
OEL - Stetcher
Bob
Stolarz.
Leafs Trade Rumors
Use our rumours form to send us leafs trade rumors.
Site last updated: 22:56:02
16 Nov 2026 04:02:13
So I'm seeing the posts about ripping it down so here's a couple ideas if you were to trade the big boys.
I think Chayka set this up so it could go either way, depending on how the results materialized this season. Every signing this summer (besides Raddysh and Marchenko) were two year deals. Scissors, Blueger, Duhaime...these are all character guys who teams love to grab at the deadline. If things went poorly, I think it was his plan to turn these players into draft picks/prospects because they are low risk, cheap deals with short term...so contending teams can grab them for a cup run.
As for Willy, I would have traded this guy years ago. He is the most frustrating player to watch and is scared to make a check or take a check. They should have sent him packing years ago and kept Marner...but here we are. Someone suggested Carolina and that might be a good spot for him as he might actually waive to go there.
Carolina: Nylander and OEL
Toronto: Jarvis and Nikishin
For those who think we aren't getting enough, Jarvis is a heck of a player, 24 yrs old and on a great contract (7.9M x 8 years). For those who think we can't get Jarvis....heck I would even take Ehlers at this point because he at least plays with some heart.
I like Auston so I'm not sure that trading him is the best option. But I do think Chayka needs to have a real conversation with him soon about if he intends to come back if things keep going off the rails. If he doesn't want to return, he again will need to go to a contender. So I still believe that best landing spot is Utah. He's close friends with Keller and Cooley and they have a great team right now! They would be instant cup contenders...if they aren't already.
Utah: Matthews
Leafs: Tig Iginla, Caleb Desnoyers, Simashev and a 1st 2027.
That is a futures package but might be what is needed.
Thoughts?
16 Nov 2026 11:54:57
Trading Matthews to Utah is a good direction. I'd want Lamoureux as part of the package aswell. There's more to his game than peoplem realize and would be a sure fire leadership role with the team. He's got top line potential but is best suited playing the hardest minutes.
And we could reatain Matthews salary for even better return.
16 Nov 2026 13:53:29
Like maybe Cooley? So Tor trades Matthews @50% retained, Utah trades 27’ 1st, C L Cooley, T Iginla, Simashev, Desnoyes, plus? Anyway, Matthews is on another level this year. Hurts to lose him. I just think by the time we right this ship, he’ll be on his major downturn; injuries, etc., would now be very present. Makes sense to move him on a high note, plus tbh he deserves legit chances at a cup with a good team.
16 Nov 2026 19:40:55
I also would have traded Willy, but probably traded both he and Mitch. Was never a fan of Marner's whining nor Bystander's lazy efforts.
16 Nov 2026 21:24:03
Lol LL. Bystander is a great name for Willy.
I’ve been yelling at this chat for years (not that I’m blaming anyone here but taking out frustration) to trade Willy, since his hold out year. He is a selfish player, all he cares about are his cookies. Can’t win with players like him. I’m so close to jumping ship, nothing this organization does makes any sense. My buddies have already starting to jump in the Oilers bandwagon. I personally like the way Boston and Utah play but always enjoy watching the Ducks - the kids over there are exciting to watch. I just don’t think ownership cares about winning games, it’s selling tickets and merch.
16 Nov 2026 02:37:56
Nylander and OEL
To the Rangers for
Cuylle, Schneider, Cole Beaudoin
1st or 2nd round pick
16 Nov 2026 02:01:00
What a 🗑️ package.
16 Nov 2026 13:56:02
Cuylle is sick champ!? The rest ya agreed but I really think Cuylle is a centre piece but we’d need a solid dman coming back. Or Cuylle and Greentree with Schneider and I’m sold. Cap space coming back plus ELC with Greentree we’d be looking good.
16 Nov 2026 18:47:50
Greentree or Beaudoin. Both big bodies but I went with Beaudoin in the offer because he’s a center.
16 Nov 2026 21:27:31
I like it! Cuyelle is a stud and a team player. Get rid of Bystander and get some heart back in the lineup would excite me. Don’t listen to Chimp but I don’t see Willy waving to go to NYR. If Willy is going to give a list at Chaykas request, you will maybe get 3 teams out of Willy and those places won’t be cold.
16 Nov 2026 02:13:52
Philly
Nylander
Danford
Leafs
Martone
Leafs 1st 2027
Brek Liske
Leafs pick trade scenario…
Top 5 protected, slides to 2027. The 2027 pick goes to Philadelphia (as part of Laughton trade) if it is outside the top 10, which converts this pick to Boston to a 2028 unprotected 1st Round Pick. If this Pick slides to 2027 and is in the top 10, TOR can either transfer it to BOS to satisfy this trade and then give PHI the 2028 unprotected, or transfer it to PHI and give BOS the 2028 unprotected 1st Round Pick.
16 Nov 2026 02:00:15
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🗑️🗑️
16 Nov 2026 11:56:33
Nylander is considered a top 5 RW in the league when he's not doing what he's doing right now. He would actually return a very healthy return. And Philly has explicitly said Martone is untouchable.
15 Nov 2026 19:30:19
Anyone else have a bad feeling Chayka is going to make a Carlo-esque trade to try and save the season?
15 Nov 2026 23:02:34
No, only u 🥴🥴🥴🥴.
16 Nov 2026 13:59:14
Buddy, he does this. I’m done!!! Enough of this s***, nope. Mats won’t let it happen. I think that’s why he’s there for that exact reason. It happens. It’s O lay o lay o lay o lay. Go Habs Go. I’ll go right the f*** offside and against them at that point. That has single handedly doomed us, that and the Philly trade, ffs.
15 Nov 2026 07:12:58
I haven’t seen the trade posted yet and I think it helps both teams
Tor: Nylander
Dal: Harley
It wasn’t long ago that Dallas tried trading Harley to Columbus, he blocked it, but I wonder how he feels about playing in Toronto… Leafs land a top pair guy and get rid of the heartless Nylander.
Why would Dallas make this trade? Well, when you look at Dallas and their contracts, one thing stands out is expiring deals of Robertson, Seguin, and Benn. Now, Seguin and Ben don’t break the bank, but Robertson was looking for 14-15 aav, plus the fact that they don’t have the depth on forward the once did.
Point being, that if they were able to bring in Nylander, they could then turn and trade Robertson for a good package/player, say like maybe a nikisin?
15 Nov 2026 13:57:48
Harley dudnt block it. Werenski did. Harley doesn’t have any trade protection until part way through his contract at the 2029/2030 season. So he is free game if Dallas was willing to trade.
15 Nov 2026 18:14:25
Would love to make this trade, but I really don't have a read on Willy. I'm not sure he actually cares if this team ever wins a game again as long as he gets paid.
14 Nov 2026 11:31:37
Tor: Sim, Joshua, Holinka, 6th
LA: Anderson
Its hard to tell where exactly LA is going, but they shou real rebuild at some point. Bringin in Anderson to help get the Leafs back on track at the expense of a cople prospects, Joshua for cap with a late late pick.
Andeson is a great skater and a left side shutdown. He can work very well with Tanev or I more see him with OEL on his right side on the bottom pairing until we can trade OEL at the deadline when his value will be highest.
14 Nov 2026 13:32:36
I would send a lefty D back the other way instead of Joshua in that package. OEL.
14 Nov 2026 14:14:30
Champ, I went with Joshua because OEL is still more valuable and is still very effective to even play on Anderson's right side. We can hopefully get the 2 playing well that we can send OEL off at the trade deadline, with an outside chance a team like Anaheim would offer even a 1st Rd pick or a 2nd + a prospect like Proczysyn (a long term prospect with middle middle to top 6 skills who's also very strong defensively, also an Ontario boy who captianed the Battalion to a playoff birth last season).
16 Nov 2026 14:07:13
Best part about seeing some of you guys coming to your senses, Champ, and your emojis, lol. Sorry, pal, had to use you’re handle specially, but…… I got eaten by so many of you narrow sited arm chair GMs like myself indeed with this team. It was never changing, boys! Glad to finally see what I’ve been saying for two seasons: trade Matthews and Nylander, Tavares, etc. Start over. We have some solid building blocks with those trades made and the cap space acquired this turn around won’t be as awful as watch the crap we are presently; it’ll actually be fun again and we’ll see how this team develops into a Montreal type problem if it’s done right!
13 Nov 2026 16:14:46
Who else is sick of watching this
Tor - Nylander, Could offer Col 1st to get this done but then Phi adds
Phi - Michkov, Tor 2027 1st
Philly has been looking for a splash move since trying for Carlsson and Michkov reportedly wants out. Tor gets a top prospect and their own pick in this draft back.
Tor - Matthews (50% retained), Raddysh, Roslovic
SJ - Misa, Verhoeff, Ravensbergen, Stenberg
Toronto trades their best player for an absolute haul. SJ aren't where they thought they would be. SJ also desperately need defence. You keep Roslovic in this deal because him and Matthews play well together.
Tor - Marchenko, McCabe, OEL
Chi - Frondell, Kantserov
Chicago gets a top line winger to play with bedard and help on D. Toronto gets 2 top prospects in return. Chicago is also desperate.
Tor - Tavares, Paul
Mon - Hage, pick
Montreal still could use a center and Tavares is cost controlled for a couple more years. Tor gets a great prospect.
Trade Reilly to whoever will take him for whatever they will give you.
Last trade does not need to be made but might be fun
After all of this Toronto has the best prospect pool in the league and hopefully drafts high with both their and Colorado 1st pick (If you still have it). With all the open salary now the leafs take on some bad contracts for more draft capital. Give the marlies a chance to play games. No contracts they take on should be more than 2 years.
In 2 years time all these kids should be pretty good and the leafs swing in free agency for McDavid, werenski, and yes....Matthews. Obviously they would not get all 3 but you try for all of them as you will have the salary available.
13 Nov 2026 17:51:05
Michkov specifically is the last player I want on this team.
13 Nov 2026 20:14:14
Don’t know about these trades but I am sick of watching this team 10 years band running now. Cottonelle Leafs.
14 Nov 2026 10:41:48
Nylander gets u Michkov and that 1st rd pick plus. What are u thinking? Michkov has proven nothing but being a burden on the bench. Nylander is a proven above point per game producer and only 29yrs old signed to a great contract for that type of production. 🥴 I won’t even comment on the rest purely 🥴
14 Nov 2026 13:03:40
I hope they get drubbed, booed off the ice and 88 sweaters FINALLY hit the ice… I’ll be savouring a cold beer.
13 Nov 2026 16:00:08
I had Matthews to Carolina, although I personally wouldn't trade him. Willy, I got going to San Jose. I've always said he suits the west coast California vibe and the Sharks play a Nylander style of game.
SJ
Nylander $11.5M
OEL $3.5M
Tor
Orlov $6.5M
Musty ELC
Verhoff unsigned
McKinney Unsigned
If any Team can afford to give up higher end prospects for immediate long term help, the Sharks would be at or near the top of that list. OEL comes in cheaper for them than Orlov saving leaving them some cap using Couture's LTIR.
Leafs take on Orlov for the year and get 2 high end prospects and 1 very solid one. Since Verhoff and McKinney are unsigned, won't need to send another contract to SJ to make it work. Could likely move Orlov at the TDL for a pick as well.
13 Nov 2026 21:00:34
Love the trade and love the return
Agree Willy is epitome of California Dreamin’.
14 Nov 2026 10:47:14
Why would you send OEL instead of Reilly who was already linked to San Jose. Now that Nurse is a complete bust there, they could use his offense on the back end. Reilly is younger and has way more value then OEL who’s playing 3rd pairing. Willy is more likely to accept a trade to a contender where he has buddies like Carolina b4 going to San Jose. San Jose doesn’t need him. They have enough flashy wingers there and a lot younger.
14 Nov 2026 14:01:39
Because of the cap and term commitment is why it is OEL and not Rielly. The trade already eats into their LTIR pool. Rielly makes 2x what OEL makes and signed twice as long. SJ is having trouble scoring this year. Celebrini leads with 8 goals. Of course Nylander would help them and it moves Smith down to 2 RW.
15 Nov 2026 14:03:25
They don’t need another 35yr old d man when they r giving u one. Couture is done, so his $8m I don’t even consider to be LTIR. If it’s cap you r worried about, then take back a guy like Goodrow and his $3.65m, which expires at the end of the season. Reilly was San Jose’s target b4 going to get Nurse. Which I’m sure Grier is regretting everyday. Cause he’s a total bust, but he wanted his homie and now got stuck with a dud at $9.25m.
12 Nov 2026 17:35:44
If the Leafs were to move Matthews and I am not suggesting they will or even should. I know many are looking at Willy going to Carolina, but I think that is a great spot for Matthews.
Car
Matthews $13.25M
Merzlikins $4.43M (For contract limit purposes. Plus if he does come back this year, he may help Carolina's goalie situation)
Tor
Kotkaniemi $4.82 (mostly for cap, but can be a 3C)
Jarvis $7.42M
Nikishin $3M
2027 1st and 2nd
Carolina would be swinging for the fence and another Cup. Two shots with Matthews. Maybe he would waive for a Cup Contender.
Leafs get 3 26 and under NHLers. Jarvis is a middle 6 responsible player with offence. Kotkaniemi a possible 3C with some size and plays a gritty game. Nikishin is a bit of a gamble, but has shown to date he may truly be a top 4 D. Leafs also get a 1st and 2nd rounder in the upcoming draft.
I know some will say no way without Stankoven or a different high end guy, but Canes are chasing a Cup. Leafs get 3 guys who are upgrades in guys they have and can now move for a return as well. Next would be Willy and you look for a high end prospect+ or young NHLer+ for him.
13 Nov 2026 00:46:46
I really think it could be a better return. This makes JT 1C and Nic Paul 2C, which is a non-playoff team.
If Mathews is moved, I call MTL and ask for every single future possible if Mathews is willing to go.
The absolute lack of D prospects and C prospects is such an issue. Idk where you're getting help on the back end or down the middle.
13 Nov 2026 13:21:47
Not trading Matthews. Willy and Reilly are the only core guys that will be traded. I think Carolina is the landing spot for Willy. Willy gets u Nikishin, a 1st rd and another top prospect. They have almost $9m in cap space so don’t need to add a guy like Koka to make it work with Nik making $3m. I would say put Martinook in there as an expiring contract if u need to balance it out. That way u don’t take anyone back with term and extend Nik for next contract. Reilly, on the other hand, would be somewhere like Seattle, and dare I say San Jose, as Nurse was a disaster trade for them. Reilly goes there and, in return, u get Orlov on an expiring contract and one of the young guys on their roster like Graf, Ostapchuk, Smith, or Cherynosov part of the return. These 2 moves frees up cap, gets u young guns back, plus a top draft pick. $19m out u r taking back $12m which 2 contracts expire at the end of the season which fees up $7m of that $12m. Leaving u with $14m in cap going into next season.
13 Nov 2026 15:11:49
Champ - I don't think Matthews get trade either, as I eluded to at the start of my post. But I do believe Carolina would be a strong destination possibility if he were to get moved. Willy would good in SJ imo. I had Rielly to SJ for Orlov in the off-season. Now, yes, Rielly should get a small plus. But I doubt it's Smith or Chernyshov.
LL. Don't see Montreal getting Matthews. Goes back to the US I think. That does seem to be the trend of US born stars.
14 Nov 2026 10:51:53
Reilly would get you one of those guys for sure cause like u stated they have an abundance of younger wingers and centres already in the lineup plus more coming up. They would definitely part with one of the 4 I mentioned. Willy would wave for Carolina and get u the return I mentioned. You have the right 2 teams in targeting just the wrong players going there IMO.
14 Nov 2026 13:57:28
Have to agree to disagree because no way Rielly gets their top line RW in Smith or one of their top prospects with size and speed in Cherny who has 23 points in 39 NHL games.
12 Nov 2026 16:50:01
Tor: Matthews
Phi: Martone, our first this year, their first this year, Sanheim
Tor: Nylander
Bos: our first, Minten, a cap dump to even out salary.
Tor: Reilly
Edm: Walman, 2027 1st
(Risky, but since we are rebuilding worth it)
Tor: Oel
Fla: 3rd
Tor: Tavares
Car: 3rd
(He's been a great leader here, give him a shot at a cup)
Activate the rebuild, start drafting some centerman, be competitive again in 5 or 6 years.
Tor: Bob 50%
Anybody desperate for a goalie at the deadline: 2nd round pick. It is a lot, but that's a lot of retention; if we can't get that for him I say we let him play out the contract as a backup.
13 Nov 2026 01:55:15
🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴
13 Nov 2026 13:30:14
Why champ??? Look back at my posts, remember pretty sure you made those same emojis when I posted the same or very similar trades in the summer. Cuz I totally saw this crap coming. Except my idea was Matthews to the Ducks for Sennecke which that ship has sailed. Oh and it included Solberg and McQueen. May have required other pcs but wow would we be looking good! Now we know for a fact Briere would be chomping at a 1C like Matthews so that first trade is exactly what our return would be
Philly get AM plus maybe a young guy in our system
Tor get our coveted 1st back O Bonk Philly’s 1st top five only protected and Jett Luchenko which is a C. Maybe switch Philly’s first this year with Sanheim if that makes it work or we retain 50% on Matthews which guarantees it and their first included.
Dunno if Willy deal happens but if we can swing it we’re all in on it.
13 Nov 2026 13:41:52
@shanny Love those ideas bud! Philly is the most probable but I think if we’re retaining 50% on Bob it should be a 1st back no? It’ll be a team swinging that thinks they might be able to go on a cup run. Which is our argument for that 1st Bob steps up huge come playoffs, that their gonna have a different goalie; a 2 time winner blah blah lol. Good post!
14 Nov 2026 10:53:10
Of course you love those ideas you’re the same person 🥴🥴🥴🤣🤣🤣
Cell phone only version of this site: https://mobile.leafs-rumours.com