Leafs Trade Rumors

Use our rumours form to send us leafs trade rumors.

Paypal single or recurring donation

This page last updated: 13:28:49

18 May 2025 12:44:39
Toronto Trades:

Austin Matthews
Matt Murray

San Jose trades:

Macklin Celebrini
Yaroslav Askarov
Tyler Toffoli

Believable0 Unbelievable0

17 May 2025 15:52:36
Leafs trade Kampf

SAN Jose 4 th 2025

The leafs have more firepower than Florida when we compare the top two lines

Tavares only has 2 points the last 6 games but Willy Nylander has 6 points in first 3 games and zero points last 3 games. He is due to play well along with Tavares

Toronto has deeper scoring than Florida
I think the Leafs have a better group of defence than Florida

Toronto = Florida in Goaltending

If Toronto gets the best game from

Knies Matthews Marner
Holmberg Tavares Nylander

X factor Pacioretty line

Leafs should win

Believable1 Unbelievable0

18 May 2025 00:19:04
The main player is still Woll. If he is really solid with NO leaky goals against, that is the most important thing imo.
Knies is unknown at the moment as we don't know how bad the injury really is.

Agree0 Disagree0

18 May 2025 03:17:41
Winnipeg had too high a hill to climb but still only three goals scored and there seemed to be much more open ice then there is in Toronto series

HELLEBUYCK gives up nasty rebound I never want him when all the chips are on the line $8.5 million Leafs pay less than that to both goalies and there goaltending is as good

Dallas are flawed in defensive zone

When Ceci is a top four defenceman it can’t be good

Edmonton probably beat Dallas

Leafs can win cup if they win tomorrow.

Agree0 Disagree0

17 May 2025 14:22:30
Some Players Toronto should try to target on July 1st

UFAS
Trent Frederick
Brett Leason
Brock Boeser
Ryan Donato
Sean Kurley
Brandon Tanev
Justin Brazeau
Brad Marchand

Players Toronto trades for picks or prospects or buyouts

Holmberg
Robertson
Jarnkroc
Kampf
Domi
McMann
Reaves

Patcherity retires

Marner signs somewhere else

Tavares signs for $6 x 3yrs or let him walk

Knies signs $6 x yrs

Lorentz resigns

Murray walks

Believable1 Unbelievable0

18 May 2025 01:17:27
Parkgardens

Some on ur trade chip list are very Cheak players than can play

Domi
McMann
Robertson
Holmberg

Domi does take dumb penalties and Kadri was run out of time for doing that. Domi is a decent playmaker and can play physical . he knocked a puck away from a Panther player last night and if his stick doesn’t get puck it’s a goal

Holmberg
McMann
Robertson

These 3 players are going to cost 1 million each and you need players who don’t earn much. So for that reason these 3 stay Leafs

Tavares maybe running out of gas 2 points in Florida series

Nylander had 6 points first 3 games 0 points last three games

I expect a big game from these two players

Pacioretty has been a great bonus helping Domi and McMann

Teams with best chance to win cup

Dallas
Edmonton
Toronto = Florida

The Jets are being dominated I give them zero chance after watching 1st period.

Agree0 Disagree1

18 May 2025 01:25:48
Dallas make bad play in own end maybe just maybe Winnipeg steal this game.

Agree0 Disagree0

18 May 2025 01:43:53
First time I watch Dallas holes in there defence. Like remember last season defence cost Leafs that’s Dallas now.

Agree0 Disagree0

16 May 2025 19:51:12
Tor: Matthews, Reilly
Cbj: fantilli, werenski, Johnson.

Move holmberg and robertson

Resign Tavares.
Resign knies
Resign lorentz
Sign mangiapane
Sign Dvorak

Leaf lines

Knies fantilli Johnson
Mangiapane Tavares nylander
Mcmann Dvorak Domi
Lorentz Laughton Kampf

Same D just swap Reilly and Werenski

I try not to go after bigger names for the slight chance mcdavid hits the open market the next year. That way we have the money to go after him and another big name.

Fantilli strikes me as a big game performer. I'm willing to take less goals if the goals he does get are more impactful

Believable0 Unbelievable0

17 May 2025 03:17:29
Can’t see CBJ’s doing something like that.
The suggested trade does not improve the Blue Jackets and could be considered a negative return in regards to what they are giving up.

Agree0 Disagree0

17 May 2025 14:34:58
Why don’t you just move to Columbus. A few hours b4 puck drop great seats are available.

Agree0 Disagree0

16 May 2025 13:36:12
Off season:
Trade:
To Utah: Matthews

To Tor: Guenther, Crouse, Doan

Let Matthews play with his buddy Keller.

**Marner walks obviously

Trade:
To Clb: 2nd rd pick 2025, 2nd rd pick 2027, Reaves, Kampf

To Tor: Olivier
Gonna take a fair bit to get him out of CBJ plus taking two potential buyouts from us m. This may not be enough. Maybe add a decent prospect to this.

Sign:
Bennet 8M X 6
JT 6.5M x 3
Knies 8M X 8
Lorentz 1.5M X 2
Holmberg 1.2M X 1

Guenther JT Nylander
Knies Bennett Crouse
McMann Laughton Domi
Lorentz Holmberg Olivier
Doan
D are set for this year.
McCabe Tanev
Reilly Carlo
Benoit OEL
Myers/ Mermis.

Believable0 Unbelievable1

17 May 2025 03:44:11
Trading a #1 center for a top line RW, a 2nd/ 3rd line LW and a 3rd line RW does not seem like a good idea to me.
Yes, Guenther can replace Marner at RW (Guenther is not a LW) when he walks but that leaves the Leafs with a 35 year old 1st line center and no 2nd or 3rd line center with very few desirable centers available in free agency.

There is Sam Bennett (though he has reportedly stated that he has no interest in returning to Canada to play hockey), Ryan Donato though Chicago is trying to resign him and Pius Suter.
The pickings for under 30 year old free agent centers is slim.

Prying Olivier out of Columbus would probably take more assets than the Leafs have unless you wish to ship Cowan or Danford out for a 4th line RW.
Outside of those two I doubt Leafs have any other prospects that Columbus Blue Jackets would want after sending Grebyonkin to the Flyers and Minten to Boston.

Laughton has already shown he is not a suitable 3rd line center (with next to no offense) and is, at best, an upgrade over Kampf as a 4th line center.

Holmberg is best left as Leafs 13th, Swiss Army Knife, 13th forward.

My thoughts on Leafs lineup next season.
Depending on how far they advance Marner might wish to return.

Knies - Matthews - Nylander
Ehlers - Donato - Boeser or Fabbri
McMann - Tavares or Pius Suter - Mason Appleton or Connor Brown
Lorentz’s- Laughton - Brazeau
Holmberg.

Agree0 Disagree0

17 May 2025 14:53:54
If Leafs lose Sunday there is no deal for Leafs and Marner. If they win I think Carolina is an easier series than the Panthers. So if Toronto win tomorrow they probably punch a ticket to the Stanley cup final against Edmonton or Dallas. Marner wants to be the highest paid player in the NHL and Leafs will let that happen if they get to the finals.

Agree0 Disagree1

16 May 2025 02:57:59
Toronto asks Matthews to waive no trade clause,

Toronto trades Matthews and Robertson

To

Utah for Logan Cooley, Nick Schalaz, Josh Doan and 2nd & 3rd in 2026

Toronto asks Rielly to waive to trade,

Toronto trades Rielly
To
Seattle for Vince Dunn

Domi asked to waive no trade if says no buy the bum out!

Sign Tavares 3yrs x 6 million or let him walk

Let Bitchy Mitchy walk

Toronto tries to sign UFAS
Brett Leason
Brock Boeser

Toronto trades McMann and Holmberg
To
Philadelphia for Tyson Forester

Believable0 Unbelievable0

16 May 2025 01:03:51
Matthews
Rielly
Domi

to Ducks

Leafs get
Cutter Gauthier
Mason McTavish
Beckett Sennecke
Tristan Luneau
Jacob Trouba

Marner walks

Kampf Jarnkrok to sharks
Leafs get 2nd 2025

Resign
Tavares
Sign
Sam Bennett
Jack Roslovic
Luke Kunin

Knies Tavares Cowan
Gauthier Bennett Nylander
McMann McTavish Roslovic
Robertson Laughton Kunin

McCabe Trouba
Benoit Tanev
OEL Carlo

Woll
Stolarz

Believable1 Unbelievable0

16 May 2025 02:49:06
Like it all but not Bennett,
That prick says he will not play in Canada!

Agree0 Disagree0

17 May 2025 04:31:35
I like the Ducks trade but I’m not sure Verbeek would trade that much youth for Matthews, Reilly and Domi.
Matthews will be 28 prior to the start of next season and seems to have been battling a recurrent wrist/ hand injury all season, Reilly is 31 (definitely on the down side of his career) while Domi is 30 years old and completely ineffective in my opinion.

Cowan is a left winger and my preference is to play players on their natural side to give them the best chance to succeed.
Putting a rookie on the 1st line, on his wrong side does not offer the best opportunity for success.

I don’t see Robertson’s style of play being suitable for a 4th line, shut down, grinder and would much prefer Lorentz’s at LW on the 4th line.

As has been mentioned, Bennett has reportedly stated he is not interested in returning to Canada to play hockey.
Leafs would probably have better luck signing Ryan Donato if he doesn’t resign with Chicago who I have read, are interested in resigning him.

Trouba is long past his days of being a top pairing defenseman and would be much better on their 3rd pair facing weaker competition.

McCabe - Tanev
OEL - Carlo
Benoit - Trouba
Myers.

Agree0 Disagree0

15 May 2025 17:57:38
Think Toronto could convince the islander to give up barzal and a 1st for Matthews?

Believable0 Unbelievable0

16 May 2025 02:49:42
Yes but no thanks on Brazal.

Agree2 Disagree0

15 May 2025 17:44:37
Tor: Matthews

Nyr: Fox, Lafreniere

Tor:Kampf

ANYBODY: ANYTHING

Tor: Jarnkrok

ANYBODY: ANYTHING

Tor: Rielly, 3rd round pick

Det: Larkin

Use the cap space to pick up some free agents

In an ideal world sign and trade Marner to a team of his choice. That has about a 1% chance of happening but would be best for the team.

* I only agree with my comment if we dont win the next two games lol *.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

17 May 2025 04:34:59
Trading Matthews for a defenseman and left winger when the only other top 9 center Leafs have is 35 year old (September) Tavares would seem to weaken the Leafs even more than they already are at a critical position, center. I like both Fox and Lafreniere but they do not suit the needs of Leafs roster.

Agree0 Disagree0

15 May 2025 15:41:22
Leafs trade Jarnknok

SAN Jose 4 th 2025

They could win 2 games in a row but I doubt it against Florida

They can't bring Marner back because if they do it's the exact team again

The truth is I don't even know why this is happening ? What players for Florida are making biggest difference

If it's SAM BENNETT they could sign him

You guys tell me who are the Leafs killers in this series