Leafs Rumours Member Posts


Davidmackin's Profile

Current Avatar:
Davidmackin's Avatar

Current Profile Picture:
Click to view larger image
Davidmackin's Profile Picture


Where from: Toronto

Favourite player: Bobby Orr

Best team moment: Two girls same time

Interests: Girls

Timezone: (GMT -5:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada), Bogota, Lima

Davidmackin's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Davidmackin's Posts



To Davidmackin's last 5 rumours posts


To Davidmackin's last 5 rumour replies


Davidmackin's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Davidmackin's rumours posts


25 Oct 2020 22:16:21
I am not saying trade Kane for marner

But in crunch time Kane is better

Leafs trade marner

Coyotes young player plus 3 first round pics

End season

1.) 26 Oct 2020 00:11:02
Why are u mentioning Kane when deal is with Arizona

The Kane vs Marner debate only makes marner look better. The fact it has an argument on both ends makes marner look awesome since Kane is awesome so thanks

Marner has 8 years to get 3 cups 1 art ross and I think an mvp but not sure on that. Brain little foggy

The fact a 23 yr old can be compared to Kane I’d totally stay away from Arizona deal and just hope marner continues to improve. None of the picks or prospects in return for marner could end up being marner


But I’m sure there is a good argument on the other end I’ll read.

2.) 26 Oct 2020 00:16:54
Coyote won't lol.

3.) 26 Oct 2020 03:37:43
Since this is the new debate I'll add my two cents.

I prefer Kane to Marner. Get that out of the way lol.

Based on stats Kane is marginally ahead. Those types of differences statistically are insignificant though.

Kane won 3 Cups Marner won zero. One thing we all forget though, Marner makes 11 now. Kane won when he and his buddy made SIGNIFICANTLY less. Leafs didn't go all in like chicago did at the time.

I do believe Kane is the better player but most of that is personal bias. I would also like a couple guys on the team with a winning attitude. JT is an older guy but he has accomplished nothing in his career. Yes, those Islanders teams weren't the best but still. I think Kane brings more of a leadership quality and an effort every night than I see from Marner. Marner looked like dog rubbish after that play-in round and then admitted he didn't really give a rubbish anyway. Those kinds of attitudes have really started to bother me about this team.

4.) 26 Oct 2020 05:06:50
I wasn’t going to get sucked in, I thought it was so obvious Mackin is on a bender and has been drunk for a week. I actually didn’t think it was even a debate. Lol. But ok. Here’s my two cents:

Nobody in their right mind trades a Marner type player for a Kane type player at their current stages of their career.

That’s all I got.

5.) 26 Oct 2020 13:03:50
Kane is a leader? Really? Off the ice he’s and idiot. No way in hell you replace Marner with Kane.

6.) 26 Oct 2020 13:12:32
David is world biggest kane fan, littlebit too much. Not serious guy Or bad troll, nothing more. Go hawks fan site telling everybody p kane is world Best player ever=) Hilarious troll. Did yoU see the forest for the trees? Maby you have to see couple Marner and couple Kane match. I think i step troll trap. I don't read anymore Davidtroll's tell stories.

7.) 26 Oct 2020 13:25:59
Considering money is almost the same and Marner is 23, you keep Marner. imo

Kane is awesome, no doubt. But with he age difference and no significant cap savings, it wouldn't make a lot of sense to me to make the move.

8.) 26 Oct 2020 16:17:47
Arizona is over the Cap and can't add Marner.

I agree with RLF: Cane IS better than Marner, but Marner has youth on his side. by 8 years.

However, IF you had a chance to trade Marner's contract for something else, I'd do it in a heartbeat. He isn't a point-per-game player, and no way he can live up to his monstrous 11M contact.

9.) 26 Oct 2020 17:08:58
He is over a point per game 1.13 over since signing that deal. If 1.13 is considered bad than marner has nothing but up to look forward too.

10.) 26 Oct 2020 17:50:27
The only player the Coyotes will overpay for is hometown boy Matthews.

11.) 26 Oct 2020 18:21:38
They already proved they overpay with that hall trade.

12.) 26 Oct 2020 19:07:43
He is over a point per game player? Wtf you talking about?

13.) 27 Oct 2020 13:07:49
Marner Career Stats:

300 GP, 83 G, 208 A, 291 Points.

All I said was I'd trade him if I could, he's NOT a PPG player, and he isn't worth almost 11M/ season.

LEAFSLIFE: you asked me WTF was I talking about. Did I get this wrong, or did you just assume with all the hype he gets he must be a point a game player? If I am wrong please let me know. I'm surprised this is news to you?

14.) 27 Oct 2020 19:30:13
He is a well over a ppg player last 2 seasons

Guess Gretzky was never a 200 point season guy since he never averaged 200 ppseason right.

15.) 27 Oct 2020 23:18:39
By your theory there are only 9 ppg players in nhl
Draisaitl (barely)

So I guess mackinnon isn’t and Pasternak isn’t and Marchand isn’t

9 guys what a boring league.



24 Oct 2020 00:41:21
End season

Remember when it's time for fans to come back . Marner can put people in seats

Toronto marner
Coyotes 3 or 4 top prospects

1.) 24 Oct 2020 06:00:22
They don't really have many prospects lol. Other issue they don't seem to want to pay anyone.

I understand why everyone is targeting the coyotes but unless Kessel comes back I don't see it.

2.) 24 Oct 2020 13:30:02
Arizona won't take on Marners contract and cap hit.

3.) 24 Oct 2020 15:45:49
But they would take Mathews.

4.) 24 Oct 2020 23:59:46
Arizona couldn’t pay the players bonuses on time this year no way they take marners nor should the leafs take anything from Arizona.



22 Oct 2020 15:40:14
Last season of marner. The salary bar is too high for what he brings. Tavares was a mistake as well but he plays Center.



BUFFALO Ristolainen Sam Reinhart. Jack Quinn and first round 2021

1.) 22 Oct 2020 16:27:59
Senators sign brown 3 years $3.6 a season. I’m happy Connor brown but that contract Ottawa will regret max brown is a 2 million a season player. Hyman can now ask 4.5 million based on Connor brown deal ridiculous.

2.) 22 Oct 2020 16:44:15
Davidmackin I totally disagree. The reason they signed him is because they know that on a team that really hasn’t done much in like 2-3 season, he can be that leader in the locker room and that guy that will average 50-60 points in your team. In Toronto he didn’t contribute much which is because of all the talent that they got on that team and the guys upfront are stacked. When he got traded I knew that he was going to restart his career and be one of there best player in Ottawa and he had and I can see him and Brady being two of the best players on the team for years to come.

3.) 22 Oct 2020 17:38:46
It will be a tough deal to make, trading Marner's 11M contract, especially in the flat cap era, but it will be necessary to icing a balanced competitive lineup.

4.) 22 Oct 2020 18:06:58
100% true Chickenfoot, that contract is an albatross. There would have to be a lot of salary coming back, and frankly it would either be one player on an equally bad contract OR two 5M ish contracts with one being a salary dump.

Many teams are operating 10+M under the cap right now, and the really good teams around the league have their core in place. Moving Marner for a fair return seems extremely unlikely over the next couple years.

This is the team's core, this is the cap situation. It's all on Dubas to make the right moves to create an effective roster of peripheral players around the core and ice a championship team.

5.) 22 Oct 2020 21:39:49
Have to agree there Chicken foot. Marner is a solid player on most teams. In a flat cap world though you will never get market value.

6.) 22 Oct 2020 22:18:28
Or Hyman can point to Kreider’s contract and say he deserves $6M a year. Their stats are eerily similar and they play a very similar style of game.

The exodus of talent and churn in the bottom of the roster since Dubas took over is going to continue annually, as Dubas has to dumpster dive to try and find “undervalued” players to backfill the bottom 6 every year. Not good.

Attempting to game the system is not an easy task. Dubas is facing an uphill battle to constantly hit winners every year and hope that Keefe can somehow squeeze value out of them all. Only to watch them sign a more lucrative contract elsewhere the next summer, so Dubas can start all over again with another crew.

I haven’t done any calculations to back this claim up, but I would not be surprised if Dubas has paid out more in salaries (in real dollars) the first two years he has taken office than ever before in the history of the NHL. He was handed a credit card with no limit and went on a spending spree. Now the consequences are catching up to him and he is having to pawn all the rest of his stuff in order to afford payment on the three (four) luxury vehicles that are taking up the bulk of his expenses.

7.) 22 Oct 2020 22:34:56
If marner is ever traded a young rhd dman is coming back
Anything less and it’s a trash trade

Marner and liljegren for makar and jost.

8.) 22 Oct 2020 23:52:41
Marner as a player is much better than this offer. Unfortunately in this flat cap era it will be hard for any team to get a decent return for players making over $9 mil with term.

9.) 23 Oct 2020 04:04:40
No chance you get Makar for Marner. Like, that isn't even close.

10.) 23 Oct 2020 07:03:15
Prove your point leafslife.

11.) 23 Oct 2020 12:24:00
Gonna laugh if Colorado pulls a 2016-17 year. Something they are good at doing. Makar and graves both go -25 and then what?

This is a team known to do this kind of crap. I don’t trust their core at all.

12.) 23 Oct 2020 14:37:28
What will it take for marner not to be fans trade scape goat

30g 95 a 125pts. Has mcdavid even done this yet?

Guess mcdavid needs a sweatner to get rid of that contract

Kane gets 90-110 pts @ 10 million per signed 2015 equates to 12 million with inflation

So is 10.85 for 90 pts really that bad?

Just like Tarasenko signing 7.5 in 2015 equates to 9 now really better than nylanders 6.9 now.

Some sign sweet deals due to location, no media pressure, the fact they sucked until year 5 get locked in great team deal then break out.

So why do fans here really want Robertson to succeed right now. Wouldn’t it be better to just let the big 4 do all work put Robertson on 3rd 4th line for 3 years have him sign team friendly deal then year 4 put on 1st line have him score 35 then all think he has best contract in league.

You all want to have these great young players to put up huge numbers during ELC but get angry when they sign big deals after succeeding beyond even your expectations. Give your heads all a shake

Coulda signed either 3 for 6.5 for 2 years but then what? Think laine will be easy

How about Keller or hischers contracts. You’d be happy with giving 50 pt guys 7-7.5 million. Just be glad leafs have 3 guys you enjoy watching. The cap isn’t our problem. Just take what we have enjoy and be glad leafs aren’t the sabres.

Why is it Habs have as a team a higher cap hit than leafs but aren’t even close to them in standings. Habs aren’t a playoff team. They beat a team they always beat in a fake made up 1st round of playoffs to create revenue and are now better than Toronto. LOL. No one discusses their bad contracts. They have many yet leafs big 4 are the discussion. It shocks me.

Matthews needs 60 goals marner 125 pts and nylander 100 just to make everyone happy. Trade them all have cap space then get lesser players have worse season but hey leafs have cap space now.

When did money and cap space become our problems.

Trade a player based on if they are good or not. Not based on the contract. It’s not our cap number who cares.

13.) 23 Oct 2020 16:40:32
C12, I understand the reason for the rant. Normally, I can see your logic in your arguments. I can agree that putting point totals to players and saying they need to post certain numbers to be worth their contract is being too tunnel visioned. imo

But to say just enjoy and forget about the cap, that I just can't see the logic.

For one-Hawks haven't won since Kane and Toews contracts kicked in. Now they feel they have to rebuild because they realized it isn't working with being too top heavy even though Toews and Kane are still at a very high level of play. And they don't have a 3rd player even close to $10M. The next is Seabrook about the same as Nylander. Their top 3 cap hits uses $5.66M less than ours and they can't truly compete.

Also, Tarasenko when originally signed would have been harder to move then, then he would be now. His hit then was 10.5% of cap, now it is down to 9.2%. That is $1M more in cap space available by comparison. Not really fair to say that is like $9M now because STL didn't win when he was at 10.5%. Blues didn't win until some of their previous, more lucrative contracts cap hits were reduced.

For Tampa, they didn't win until some of those players cap hit% were reduced by the growing cap and allowed them to surround those players with better quality. The Caps, The Pens, are also examples of the same thing. Stamkos, Hedman, Kilorn, Johnson all signed 4+ years prior to winning. They took up 35.2% of the cap when signed. Only 31.7% when they won. That is $2.85M more cap space to use elsewhere. Coburn also took a pay cut 3 years ago. With the signings of Kucherov and Vasilevskiy they still needed top quality play from ELC's Cirelli, Sergachev and Cernak along with cheap quality fillers to win.

Cap matters and with it being flat, if we win with the current allocation, it goes against everything cap history has taught us.

There is a hard budget.
If Leafs were a car being built, we put 50% of our hard budget into the engine and it is hard to say right now if we left enough for quality brakes to stop the vehicle or enough for quality tires to keep it on the road. A little less power and better brakes and tires would make a better balanced car that could handle all conditions and not just straightaways. I'd rather a balanced car then say, wow engine sounds awesome, who cares if I make the corner at the end of the straightaway:)

14.) 23 Oct 2020 18:38:31
It’s not our cap though. Can’t worry about something out of our hands. What happens if leafs win cup?

Then where does all this go?

My point to all this was instead of harpin on the players because they excelled as teenagers enjoy them for what they do. You could see leafs locked into worse contracts. Money isn’t the fans problems. Harp on a player because they suck not because you think their contract sucks.

You all loved marner Matthews and nylander making 900 gs. Money changes how good they are? Guess we should all be locked into our starting teenage wages 4-life. Wouldn’t that be fun.

15.) 23 Oct 2020 19:21:18
A little over the top. lol

I mean, all trade suggestions, fantasy or not, must take the cap into consideration in order to be even remotely possible.

I think most (I guess not all) are trying to look at ways they believe to build a Cup team, not hating on a particular player or players. I doubt anyone is mad because Matthews, Marner and Nylander are good and I doubt anyone would care what they made if the cap didn't exist.

So making trade suggestions based on ones opinion of the best way to improve the team may include moving a high ticket player and replacing him with lower cost or multiple players or prospects, picks whatever.
Personally, I would like to keep all 4, but I don't believe that is the path to the cup. Nothing to do with harping on a guy or not enjoying watching him play.

And what happens if the Leafs don't win the cup because we lacked the proper depth and all 4 walk at the end of their deals? Do we just say, well at least we kept the 4 together? Did we not possibly miss a great opportunity because maybe the build concept was flawed? There is an argument for keeping all 4 and an argument for moving 1 or even more than 1.

16.) 23 Oct 2020 21:19:39
Guess Dermott is new king of trades

Based on cap hit his worth is any + 5 million guy plus a 1st for him alone.

Can’t have it both ways now can yeah

If big 4 worth is crap than Dermott is a kings ransom.

17.) 23 Oct 2020 21:22:46
I just love going back and forth this cap thing

Some days I’ll agree others I defend the players. Lol

That’s why I love my job. Evaluating talent before money is involved.

Money complicates everything not just in hockey folks


18.) 27 Oct 2020 16:33:48
CRAIG: you listed some numbers above relating to Marner vs McDavid. It wasn't clear what stat you were trying to put across, and I'd like to. McDavid is AMAZING, and is a career 1.33 PPG.

Regarding your belief regarding the cap not being important to consider, I respectfully disagree. If you have a player locked up at 11M, but he performs like a 6M player, your team has a limited ceiling. With a hard cap there is simply no way around the principles of cap management. Perhaps I misunderstood your point regarding the cap?



21 Oct 2020 20:50:10
Next offseason leafs marner
Detroit Mantha 1st round pick 2021 not protected Lucas Raymond Moritz Seider

1.) 21 Oct 2020 21:23:09
Absolutely zero chance stevey Y does this. He would be insane to do so.

2.) 22 Oct 2020 06:14:02
Remember what offer sheet would cost 5 first round picks. Your only getting 3 plus Mantha. When it’s time to trade marner the price is high and marner will go b4 Nylander in my opinion.

3.) 22 Oct 2020 07:14:00
4 1st round picks is actually what it would cost. Also remember, only one team was willing to offer sheet for that and wanted 7 years not 5.

It also wasn't a team in the same spot as detroit it was CBJ who believes they are close to contention.

Many variables in you theory.

4.) 22 Oct 2020 14:19:56
I don't think a rebuilding team is going to trade away their best ELC assets to get one superstar at a 10.9 cap hit. They would have traded the guys they eventually want to surround Marner with.



19 Oct 2020 12:39:15
Trade kerfoot for cheap futures

Arizona a second or third round pick

If kerfoot and Vesey give you same production sign another Vesey type for $900k and ditch big ticket Kerfoot

1.) 19 Oct 2020 14:05:39
If VAN traded a 3rd for Schmidt what do u think the Leafs would get Kerfoot?

2.) 19 Oct 2020 15:05:42
Ok a seventh for kerfoot just get him gone. You find a cheaper version of kerfoot.

3.) 19 Oct 2020 15:44:48
Kerfoot at 3.5 is fine. The issue for him on Toronto is that he is a 3rd line centre at that and we are so cap heavy on the top 4, a 3rd line centre making 3.5 is too much. He is a good player, we just can't afford him.

4.) 20 Oct 2020 01:09:01
Someone really hates Kerfoot.

5.) 20 Oct 2020 14:31:43
Arizona is almost 3M OVER the salary cap. in what universe does this proposal make any sense?

P. S. You're not getting a 2nd or a 3rd for Kerfooot. most cap dumps need a sweetener.

6.) 20 Oct 2020 19:19:13
He isn't a cap dump. I'm not sure why you think everyone the leafs have is a cap dump.




Davidmackin has no Talk Posts



Davidmackin's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

30 Oct 2020 12:08:30
When its time to put people in seats Arizona will do a big move. By the end of next season it will be apparent who to trade Marner or Nylander but this is last year of big 4 Matthews Tavares Nylander Marner.



Click To View This Thread

25 Oct 2020 15:51:14
Funny how leafs fought Nylander so hard but caved into Marner and after two seasons he hasn’t come close to earning his ticket. The bar to earn 10.5 million must be Patrick Kane. Marner isn’t anywhere near Kane who is coming up on 32 years old.



Click To View This Thread

25 Oct 2020 02:59:44
I don’t trade Marner for Kane but it does show you what marner has to become to justify his contract and he isn’t close to it.



Click To View This Thread

23 Oct 2020 22:05:31
Dermott signed so cheap amazing.



Click To View This Thread

22 Oct 2020 16:27:59
Senators sign brown 3 years $3.6 a season. I’m happy Connor brown but that contract Ottawa will regret max brown is a 2 million a season player. Hyman can now ask 4.5 million based on Connor brown deal ridiculous.




Davidmackin has no Talk Replies